Singita is the choice for contemporary design and a wellness-led stay, Royal Malewane for classic old-world elegance and master-level guiding, and andBeyond for the widest choice of experiences and destinations. All three are excellent. The right one depends on what you want your days to feel like.
This is an editorial comparison based on each brand's published information. Rates and details change, so confirm with each operator. Elementa Africa is not affiliated with any of the three.
Singita: design, wine and wellness
Singita is known for contemporary, design-led lodges set in some of Africa's most protected private land. In South Africa it operates in the Sabi Sand reserve and on a private concession inside Kruger National Park, and its portfolio extends to Tanzania, Zimbabwe and Rwanda.
What sets it apart is a cohesive aesthetic, a strong food and wine culture and a growing emphasis on wellness. Its lodges are small by design, and its published rates sit in the highest bracket of the Sabi Sand.
Royal Malewane: classic elegance and expert guiding
Royal Malewane sits in the Thornybush Game Reserve in the Greater Kruger and belongs to the family-owned Royal Portfolio. The style is colonial-inspired, with thatched suites, private plunge pools and attentive butler-style service. It is known for tracker and ranger qualifications that rank among the deepest in the industry, and it also sits in the top price bracket.
andBeyond: breadth, hospitality and conservation
andBeyond is the largest of the three, with lodges across Africa and beyond, from Phinda and Ngala in South Africa to camps in East Africa and Botswana, and a lodge on Benguerra Island in Mozambique. It is widely praised for warm, consistent hospitality and for conservation work tied to local communities.
Its range is the broadest, from intimate lodges to private homesteads that suit families and groups. That breadth also means the experience varies more from one andBeyond property to the next than it does across a smaller collection.
Side by side
| Singita | Royal Malewane | andBeyond | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Design | Contemporary, design-led | Classic, colonial-inspired | Varies by lodge |
| Guiding | Excellent, conservation-led | Industry-leading tracker and ranger depth | Strong and consistent |
| Scale | Small lodges, several countries | A small collection in the Greater Kruger | Large portfolio across Africa |
| Families | Selected lodges and villas | Suites suit couples; private houses for groups | Broadest family offering |
| Atmosphere | Modern, refined, wellness-minded | Formal, romantic, old-world | Warm, polished, adventurous |
| Price position | Top bracket | Top bracket | Wide range; top properties priced alongside the other two |
How to choose
- Choose Singita if you love modern design, great food and wine, and a sense of calm.
- Choose Royal Malewane if you want classic luxury, private suites and some of the best guiding available.
- Choose andBeyond if you want choice across destinations, family-friendly options or a multi-country itinerary.
Where a private circuit is different
All three are brands built around places. A private circuit is built around a journey. Elementa is a small private group led personally by our co-founder TJ, a career safari guide, across Zambia, Zimbabwe, Mozambique and Malawi. If you want to stay in one great lodge, the brands above are superb. If you want to move through four countries with one guide and a wellness thread running through it, that is a different thing entirely. Our note on single-lodge versus multi-country safaris explores the trade-off, and what a luxury safari costs per night and how to compare quotes will help you weigh price.
Sources: each operator's own website, linked above. Details were checked in November 2026.
Frequently asked questions
Which is more expensive, Singita or Royal Malewane?
Both sit in the highest price bracket. Compare the specific suite and season, because rates change each year.
Is andBeyond cheaper than Singita?
andBeyond covers a wider price range and usually offers more entry points, but its top properties are priced alongside Singita.
Which is best for families?
andBeyond has the broadest family offering, though some Singita lodges and Royal Malewane private houses also welcome children.
Which has the best guiding?
All three invest heavily in guides. Royal Malewane is especially known for its tracker and ranger qualifications.


